Playstation Tech Support

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Saturday, 13 July 2013

Fiorillo: Better Randi than no union at all

Posted on 04:11 by Unknown
The fundamental nature of the lack of democracy internally is a bigger threat to the life of the union than the external - in the long run.
I hope you've been following the over 200 comments on Diane Ravitch's blog from people all over the nation, many of whom have learned a lot from us here in NYC on how the AFT and UFT operates. Diane began with a post about her relationship with Randi Weingarten My Friend, Randi Weingarten which opened up a firestorm of criticism of Randi and in some cases unfairly to Diane for posting this. But Diane doesn't censor comments and I'm sure our union officials are not happy over the overwhelming thumbs down on Randi -- we don't even see the usual Unity hacks showing up to defend her.

But as we've been discussing in MORE, the failure of the union on so many levels creates a dangerous internal anti-union - rather than anti-union leadership which leads people to call for ending dues check-off, mandatory dues and other right wing wet dreams. I understand the frustration, especially in the UFT where even if we organized a CORE like caucus with wide outreach, we still would be far from being able to win more than a few meaningless positions. The fundamental nature of the lack of democracy internally is a bigger threat to the life of the union than the external - in the long run.

Below is Michael Fiorillo's response to a call for abandoning unions. And let me also affirm what Michael says about Randi: – who, by the way, has always been accessible and respectful to me personally, and toward whom I harbor no personal animosity....

In my case I have been particularly critical of Randi's leadership since 2001. Yet every time I see her she is friendly and personable and accessible. I know some people see this is smart politics but I am not getting into motivation. If it is politics on her part it works to the extent that we can manage to keep the discussion on a political, not personal, level.
in response to H.A. Hurley:

It may be time to abandon the unions. I can’t think of any beneficial reason to teachers for their purpose, at this time. We used to be able to count on them and I have received their assistance on several occasions. If teachers join for liability insurance only – one can get it much cheaper [...]

While it might be tempting for some teachers to imagine other uses for the money that now goes to union dues, the fact remains that unions are the ONLY institution in the country that exist to defend the rights of working people.
The worst, most corrupt union is still better than no union at all. Despite my criticisms of Randi – who, by the way, has always been accessible and respectful to me personally, and toward whom I harbor no personal animosity – and the UFT leadership, I have no illusions that my life would be better without the union, and nor should any other teacher.
Just as the public schools need to be taken back by the public and reformed in accordance with democratic principles, in the interest of Democracy itself, so too the unions must be democratized and re-energized. Those processes would occur together, and reinforce each other.
As for Diane posting about her friendship with Randi, why should anyone have a problem with it? Diane occasionally writes on the convergence of personal and political matters, and those are important discussions to have.
As for any inferences about her motivation, I take what she writes at face value, and am grateful for the platform her post gave opponents of Randi to educate teachers and AFT members in other parts of the country.
That this forum is so open and wide-ranging, and that the level of discussion and debate remain as high as they do – things that Diane has assiduously cultivated on this blog – guarantees that the truth will assert itself and be recognized among the readership.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Video: Chicago Students Tossed From Board of Education Meeting
    Video of Chicago students taking over the Board of Education Meeting to save schools, prevent education cuts. From Xian Barrett: Published o...
  • Cavanagh Refused to Cooperate with NY Post Article on Mulgrew "Chicken" on Debate
    Every day I am reminded why Julie Cavanagh is not just MORE's presidential candidate but a true leader and why I defer to someone half m...
  • Change the Stakes to Discuss DOE's Bankrupt Student Promotion Policies, MORE Study Group on HST
    Our meetings are always open and all are welcome.  I can guarantee a lively discussion!  Promotion policies will be the focus on the agenda...
  • Parents Present Pearson With $38 Million Invoice for Use of Child Labor for Field Tests
    VISIT CHANGE THE STAKES Press Contacts: Kemala Karmen optout@parentvoicesny.org                                 Janine Sopp   janinesopp@gm...
  • I Echo Jersey Jazzman in Support for CORE in CTU Election on Friday
    Aside from everything else, just look at the ed deformers supporting Karen Lewis' opponents: The soon to be owned by Koch brothers Chica...
  • As Ed Deform Failures Mount, Mid-Course Correction for Former Cheerleaders Merrow, Goldstein, Weingarten
    Cheating is not the problem that must be addressed. It is the most visible and disturbing symptom of the disease, but the disease itself...
  • DOE Retaliates Against Children Who Opted-Out
    No matter how smart they are, the majority of kids who did not take standardized tests will be forced to attend summer school. ... Take...
  • MORE Weekly Update #65, Sept. 2, 2013
    Happy Labor Day from MORE! View this email in your ...
  • Dana Goldstein on L.A. Teacher Alex Caputo-Pearl and the Real Deal Behind Closing Schools
    On Monday, half the teachers at Crenshaw High School in Los Angeles found out they had been dismissed from their jobs as part of a "c...
  • "Waiting for Superman Makes List of Famous Documentaries That Were Shockingly Full of Crap
    Waiting for "Superman" -- Charter Schools Kind of Suck, Too [NOTE: SEE OUR RESPONSE TO WFS HERE] Read more: http://www.cracked....

Categories

  • 3020a hearing
  • Achievement First
  • achievement gap
  • AFT
  • AFT. UFT
  • Alex Caputo-Pearl
  • Andrew Cuomo
  • Anthony Weiner
  • APPR
  • arne duncan
  • atr
  • Barbara Byrd-Bennett
  • Barbara Morgan
  • Beth Hawkins
  • Bill de Blasio
  • Bill di Blasio
  • Bill Gates
  • Bill Keller
  • Bill Thompson
  • Brian Lehrer
  • Cami Anderson
  • Campbell Brown
  • Carol Burris
  • Chancellor Dennis Walcott
  • Change the stakes
  • Charles Blow
  • charter school
  • charter co-locations
  • charter school hearings
  • charter school lobby
  • charter schools
  • Chicago
  • Chicago Teachers Union
  • Chris Cerf
  • Christine Quinn
  • Christine Rubino
  • Citizens of the World charter
  • closing schools
  • Co-locations
  • Colocations
  • common core
  • Common Core Standards
  • Confessions of a Bad Teacher
  • Corey Booker
  • Danielson
  • Danielson framwork
  • David Steiner
  • Dearborn
  • Deborah Kenny
  • Democracy Prep
  • Dennis Van Roekel
  • Dennis Walcott
  • DFER
  • Diane Ravitch
  • District 14
  • drones
  • E3MN
  • E4E
  • ed deform
  • Education Nation
  • education reform
  • Educators 4 excellence
  • educators for excellence
  • eduwonkette
  • Eric Grannis
  • Erminia Claudio
  • Eva Moskowitz
  • Eva Moskowtiz
  • Evaluations
  • FairTest
  • field tests
  • Francesco Portelos
  • Fred Smith
  • Gates foundation
  • George Schmidt
  • Gotham schools
  • hannah Nguyen
  • Harlem Success Academy
  • Harlem Village Academy
  • high stakes testing
  • high stakes tests
  • High-Stakes Testing
  • House of Cards
  • ICE
  • inBloom
  • Jeb Bush
  • Jennifer Jennings
  • Jennifer Jones Rogers
  • Joe Lhota
  • Joel Klein
  • John B King
  • John King
  • John Liu
  • John Merrow
  • John Owens
  • jonathan halabi
  • Julie Cavanagh
  • Karen Lewis
  • KIPP
  • La Casita
  • LATU
  • Leo Casey
  • Leonie Haimson
  • Leticia James
  • Malcolm Smith
  • Matt Damon
  • mayoral control
  • mayoral election
  • Merryl Tisch
  • Mexico Teachers
  • Michael Benjamin
  • Michael Mulgrew
  • Michelle Rhee
  • Milton Friedman
  • MORE
  • MOSL
  • Movement of Rank and File Educators
  • Murry Bergtraum HS
  • National Education Association
  • nea
  • neo-liberalism
  • New Action
  • New Action-UFT
  • New Action/UFT
  • NEW Caucus
  • New Orleans
  • New York State Education Department
  • Newark
  • NPR
  • NY State Education Department
  • NY State Teacher Evaluations
  • NY Times
  • NY-GPS
  • NYC Teacher Evaluations
  • NYCDOE
  • nycore
  • NYSED
  • Obamacare
  • Office of Portfolio Planning
  • opt-out
  • Panel for educational policy
  • Paul Krugman
  • Paul Vallas
  • PAVE Academy
  • Pearson
  • PEP
  • pre-k
  • PS 15K
  • Public Advocate
  • race to the top
  • Rahm Emanuel
  • Rand Paul
  • Randi Weingarten
  • Reed Hastings
  • Reign of Error
  • Reza Aslan
  • Rockaway Theatre Company
  • scab
  • school closings
  • Seattle Teachers Association
  • Shael Polakow-Suransky
  • Skinny Awards
  • social justice unionism
  • SOS
  • Students United for Public Education
  • Substance
  • Success Academy
  • Success Charter Network
  • SUPE
  • Susan Fuhrman
  • Susan Ohanian
  • TDA
  • Teach for America
  • teacher data reports
  • teacher evaluation
  • teacher evaluations
  • Teachers College
  • TFA
  • The Daily Howler
  • The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Superman
  • The Wave
  • this week in ed notes
  • Tim Wise
  • Tony Avella
  • town hall
  • Tweed
  • Twinkie
  • UFT
  • UFT charter school
  • UFT elections
  • UFT history
  • union busting
  • Unity Caucus
  • WAGPOPS
  • Waiting for Superman
  • Washington DC
  • Win Back Wednesday
  • wnyc
  • Zealot
  • Zeke Vanderhoek

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  October (71)
    • ►  September (80)
    • ►  August (70)
    • ▼  July (66)
      • E4E Gets Another $3 million from Gates Foundation
      • Unflappable Weiner Press Spokesperson Barbara Morg...
      • Principal From Hell Jennifer Rogers: Parents Call ...
      • What Next From FOX? Challenging a Jew for Daring t...
      • Perdido Street on Thompson: Political Hack And Wal...
      • The Little Theater That Could: Rockaway Cafe: The ...
      • Andy Borowitz: Weiner Names New Campaign Manager
      • George Schmidt: Why every Substance reporter shoul...
      • I Won't Post Video of Amateur Actor/Teacher's Mock...
      • High Turnout at MORE Summer Event Overflows the Space
      • July 25 4-7PM - MORE Summer Series: How Should We ...
      • Randi Weingarten Proves She's an Ed Deformer, Mulg...
      • Support Teacher/Parent Marie Corfield for Assembly...
      • Joe Williams' DFER Propaganda Laugh Riot, Lauding ...
      • Newark's NEW Caucus on Chicago Layoffs
      • Jeff Kaufman Covers Trayvon Martin Protest in Los ...
      • This Was The Week That Was: Norms Social Notes
      • Newark Schools for Sale: Cami Anderson, Cerf Keep ...
      • Reposted: Kerrie Dalman, president of Colorado tea...
      • Call for Waiver from teacher evaluations in NY
      • Gotham Schools Funders: You Get What You Pay For
      • NYC Teacher Bloggers on the Loose: Slam Gotham Sch...
      • EIA: Louisiana has the rare combination of high sp...
      • You Get What You Pay For - from a NYC Parent
      • How Do They Loathe Us? - Fred Smith's Sonnet to Ti...
      • Edushyster Blows Up Democracy Prep 100% Grad Rate ...
      • Bruce Baker: Charters are Parasites
      • Gary Gives Advice to an upcoming TFAer
      • Newark Confidential - Turnaround Children Inc. Tr...
      • Weiner owes bump in the polls to black voters, Spi...
      • Video – MORE Summer 2013: High Stakes Testing and ...
      • Critics of Tim Wise for Support for Teach For America
      • Stop and Frisk: My Articles in The Wave
      • Eat a Twinkie, Be a Scab
      • Teach For America's Civil War: Organizing Resistan...
      • NYDN: Charter school funding balloons during Mayo...
      • Martin Van Buren HS Community fight back against c...
      • Lois Weiner on the Survival of Unions and Why Chic...
      • Fiorillo: Better Randi than no union at all
      • Campbell Brown Calls for Arrest of Lucas, Disgrace...
      • Success Academy Evil Moskowitz Sues on State Audit...
      • TODAY MORE Summer Series 4-7pm
      • DOE Retaliates Against Children Who Opted-Out
      • Ravitch Friends Randi, Fiorillo and Many Others Ob...
      • Protest at Tweed Over Racist Comments Draws a Crow...
      • Mercedes Schneider on Another Vallas Scam: New Orl...
      • DOENUTS IS BACK With a New Blogger
      • MORE Summer Series Begins Thursday, 4PM: High Sta...
      • Arthur Goldstein Featured in Queens Chronicle on m...
      • Why is the AFT Giving Credence to a Much Disparage...
      • Monday July 8th Noon Picket demanding an immediate...
      • Diane Ravitch, Susan Ohanian Battle the Mean Machi...
      • A Chicago Teacher's Action Inspires Antitest Crusa...
      • When in the course of human events....
      • George Schmidt Rebuts Defense of Paul Vallas on Ra...
      • Bob Peterson at NEA: Friends we are at war/ Protes...
      • George Schmidt Rakes Over Paul Vallas: Liar, Crook...
      • Killing Union Dues: Now, Michigan
      • Revolt Brewing in NEA As Van Roekel Does a Randi, ...
      • Exploring Implications of Washington DC Union Elec...
      • Coming Soon to a State Near You: Another Attack on...
      • Candi is Dandy as Her Slate Wins Washington DC Uni...
      • Joel Klein Teaching Resume: Sept/Oct 1968 During T...
      • The Onion: Progressive Charter School Doesn’t Have...
      • MEDIA ALERT: Queens Teachers Warned DOE Officials ...
      • Getting ready for the end of the world... or a PEP...
    • ►  June (62)
    • ►  May (60)
    • ►  April (67)
    • ►  March (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile