Playstation Tech Support

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 10 October 2013

Reflections on the Common Core and High Stakes Testing from Change the Stakes Member(s)

Posted on 20:59 by Unknown
Fred, you've got an oped here that needs to get wide circulation right now. One of the worst things Bloomberg has done is successfully portray the UFT as his opponent. Talk about convenient; you can score points by trashing the union while its leadership essentially does your bidding. The general public is oblivious to the fact that the union leadership not support teachers or parents or students in the face of the onslaught of destructive policies from the state. Your response to Mulgrew really brings this home.  ... Jeff, CTS
In defense of his controversial statement opposing the consequences of high-stakes testing, Michael Mulgrew, UFT President for Life, issued the following statement:
"I'm against the use of guns and rifles to kill people, but strongly believe we need to improve the design of Uzis and assault weapons. I wouldn't want to offend the NRA...  Fred Smith
The UFT loves the common bore. So does Bill Gates, Joel Klein, Dennis Walcott, Exon-Mobil. Here is some commentary by Rosalie Friend, a retired college teacher and a member of Change the Stakes.
Some parents in Change the Stakes raised questions about just what the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) meant for our students.   I am spelling out my own take on the CCSS after a career as a reading specialist.  I have tried to avoid being technical or using jargon, and I hope I have something to contribute to the discussion.
    When the Common Core State Standards were first unveiled, the International Reading Association was supporting them.   I liked the idea of deeper processing and critical thinking.  Still, I was not sure: if children were not meeting the NCLB standards, how would it help to set higher standards??  In math the claim was that they would cover fewer topics in greater depth each year.  US math curricula have been criticized as being a mile wide and an inch deep.
     Standard procedure in education requires that a new curriculum or major change in instruction must be field tested on a small sample of students and then on a large representative sample to determine whether it works as planned.  It should be modified until it works well enough to be used.  The CCSS were never field tested, leading many to feel that our children were being subjected to something untried, untested, and unknown.

    When I read the ELA standards for middle grades in depth, they did not sound unreasonable.  These were standards, not curricula.  They listed examples of materials that might be used, not required materials.  They espoused writing and critical thinking instead of exercises and workbooks.
    As I saw how the standards were being implemented, and read the comments of others, I liked the CCSS less and less.  There is a consensus that the primary grade standards are terrible inappropriate for the developmental stage of the children.  If we are to raise achievement of the older children, we must start by improving instruction in the early grades, but introducing tasks that are not developmentally appropriate, does not improve instruction.
     To me, the notion of "close reading," not linking what is read to prior knowledge, is insanity.  For the last 20 years cognitive psychology has been based on the idea that learning requires the mental construction of webs of linked memories.  If memories are not linked with other ideas and processes, they cannot be retrieved!!  If what is learned can't be retrieved for use in new situations, it is worthless.  This outlook was central whole career and my research, so I am horrified at the idea that David Coleman and his CCSS crew would have us set it aside.  When I speak to other reading faculty who did not specialize as much in this aspect of reading, they are also horrified by "close reading."
     The idea of having children do more thinking and more writing is very dear to my notions of progressive education, so when I see the new tests still using multiple choice questions, I am flabbergasted.  How can you test critical thinking using multiple choice tests?  Isn't the point of critical thinking to teach children to wrestle with real questions that don't have a single right answer?
     If you want to teach children to write well, you must have small enough classes so that teachers can critique children's compositions.  Especially in middle school and high school, if you have 145 students, you cannot read and critique a composition by every student every week.
     Another horrifying problem is that SMART and PARCC, the two consortia creating the common core exams, intend to use computers to grade essay questions.  I cannot believe that computers will be good judges of coherence and rhetoric.  I am sure that they will not be able to recognize and reward originality.
     Thus, I have concluded that I cannot in good faith, support the use of the Common Core State Standards as they are being implemented.
Mike Schirtzer from MORE commented:
As a student of psychology, especially Piaget, Gardner, and Chomsky- I have to say this is an amazing analysis!
I teach high school psych and we always look at the cognitive process, why thinking critically is better for development than rote memorization. It is clear the common core and standardized testing stands against all cognitive research of what is most effective for a sound education.
 Here's some comments from Fred Smith and others on Mulgrew's new baby spawned by the activities of MORE -- a reso calling for a moratorium on the impact of testing - until Tweed gets materials into the hands of teachers --- a grubby little reso they pushed at the DA yesterday -- but I won't get into those weeds and wait to show you some video.

Fred Smith, Change the Stakes:
Wrong, Michael.

You need a moratorium not on the high-stakes consequences of the tests--you need a moratorium on the tests themselves. How convenient it is to now call for a thoughtful examination of the 2014 exams. What about the core-aligned 2013 tests? What about the past year that was wasted fighting about them and getting nothing of educational value in return. Where's the call for an investigation of a massive "core-aligned" testing scam--the results of which can't be compared to testing that came before nor provide a meaningful baseline for whatever surprises are coming next.

Yes, the DOE is to blame for senseless test-related policies. But get real. Where's your outrage at Regents Chancellor Merryl Tisch, Education Commissioner John King and all the other SED operatives who perpetrated the Common Core fraud on all of us on your ineffective watch.

How long did it take you to come up with this tortured formulation, this mealy-mouthed moratorium on the consequences of something that is inarguably a disaster. We need an indefinite moratorium on ill-conceived tests for which SED will never have its act together, Pal--period, end.

We need to exalt teachers and their professionalism, nurture and develop them, foster the natural overpowering alliance they should have with parents (that somehow the UFT never forges), and dismantle the current testing regimen that you would rather refine than replace with authentic assessment of student progress over the school year, as observed and judged by teachers.

This will never happen by calling for a moratorium on the consequences of testing -- but not for a moratorium on the cause--the costly, defective testing engine that has driven education over the cliff.

As we used to say, Michael--Lead, follow or get the hell out of the way!

Fred Smith

Loretta Prisco
Yep, Fred, the only way to go. As long as those tests are given there will be abuses and an incredible amount of money spent that would be much better spent on lowering class size and resources for the classroom.  And Mulgrew must know that - as does every teacher.  The most damaging aspect is that our kids are being denied the education they deserve.  They only get one bite of the apple and for many it is too late.

 Jeff, Change the Stakes
Fred, you've got an oped here that needs to get wide circulation right now. One of the worst things Bloomberg has done is successfully portray the UFT as his opponent. Talk about convenient; you can score points by trashing the union while its leadership essentially does your bidding. The general public is oblivious to the fact that the union leadership not support teachers or parents or students in the face of the onslaught of destructive policies from the state. Your response to Mulgrew really brings this home.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Video: Chicago Students Tossed From Board of Education Meeting
    Video of Chicago students taking over the Board of Education Meeting to save schools, prevent education cuts. From Xian Barrett: Published o...
  • Cavanagh Refused to Cooperate with NY Post Article on Mulgrew "Chicken" on Debate
    Every day I am reminded why Julie Cavanagh is not just MORE's presidential candidate but a true leader and why I defer to someone half m...
  • Change the Stakes to Discuss DOE's Bankrupt Student Promotion Policies, MORE Study Group on HST
    Our meetings are always open and all are welcome.  I can guarantee a lively discussion!  Promotion policies will be the focus on the agenda...
  • Parents Present Pearson With $38 Million Invoice for Use of Child Labor for Field Tests
    VISIT CHANGE THE STAKES Press Contacts: Kemala Karmen optout@parentvoicesny.org                                 Janine Sopp   janinesopp@gm...
  • I Echo Jersey Jazzman in Support for CORE in CTU Election on Friday
    Aside from everything else, just look at the ed deformers supporting Karen Lewis' opponents: The soon to be owned by Koch brothers Chica...
  • As Ed Deform Failures Mount, Mid-Course Correction for Former Cheerleaders Merrow, Goldstein, Weingarten
    Cheating is not the problem that must be addressed. It is the most visible and disturbing symptom of the disease, but the disease itself...
  • DOE Retaliates Against Children Who Opted-Out
    No matter how smart they are, the majority of kids who did not take standardized tests will be forced to attend summer school. ... Take...
  • MORE Weekly Update #65, Sept. 2, 2013
    Happy Labor Day from MORE! View this email in your ...
  • Dana Goldstein on L.A. Teacher Alex Caputo-Pearl and the Real Deal Behind Closing Schools
    On Monday, half the teachers at Crenshaw High School in Los Angeles found out they had been dismissed from their jobs as part of a "c...
  • "Waiting for Superman Makes List of Famous Documentaries That Were Shockingly Full of Crap
    Waiting for "Superman" -- Charter Schools Kind of Suck, Too [NOTE: SEE OUR RESPONSE TO WFS HERE] Read more: http://www.cracked....

Categories

  • 3020a hearing
  • Achievement First
  • achievement gap
  • AFT
  • AFT. UFT
  • Alex Caputo-Pearl
  • Andrew Cuomo
  • Anthony Weiner
  • APPR
  • arne duncan
  • atr
  • Barbara Byrd-Bennett
  • Barbara Morgan
  • Beth Hawkins
  • Bill de Blasio
  • Bill di Blasio
  • Bill Gates
  • Bill Keller
  • Bill Thompson
  • Brian Lehrer
  • Cami Anderson
  • Campbell Brown
  • Carol Burris
  • Chancellor Dennis Walcott
  • Change the stakes
  • Charles Blow
  • charter school
  • charter co-locations
  • charter school hearings
  • charter school lobby
  • charter schools
  • Chicago
  • Chicago Teachers Union
  • Chris Cerf
  • Christine Quinn
  • Christine Rubino
  • Citizens of the World charter
  • closing schools
  • Co-locations
  • Colocations
  • common core
  • Common Core Standards
  • Confessions of a Bad Teacher
  • Corey Booker
  • Danielson
  • Danielson framwork
  • David Steiner
  • Dearborn
  • Deborah Kenny
  • Democracy Prep
  • Dennis Van Roekel
  • Dennis Walcott
  • DFER
  • Diane Ravitch
  • District 14
  • drones
  • E3MN
  • E4E
  • ed deform
  • Education Nation
  • education reform
  • Educators 4 excellence
  • educators for excellence
  • eduwonkette
  • Eric Grannis
  • Erminia Claudio
  • Eva Moskowitz
  • Eva Moskowtiz
  • Evaluations
  • FairTest
  • field tests
  • Francesco Portelos
  • Fred Smith
  • Gates foundation
  • George Schmidt
  • Gotham schools
  • hannah Nguyen
  • Harlem Success Academy
  • Harlem Village Academy
  • high stakes testing
  • high stakes tests
  • High-Stakes Testing
  • House of Cards
  • ICE
  • inBloom
  • Jeb Bush
  • Jennifer Jennings
  • Jennifer Jones Rogers
  • Joe Lhota
  • Joel Klein
  • John B King
  • John King
  • John Liu
  • John Merrow
  • John Owens
  • jonathan halabi
  • Julie Cavanagh
  • Karen Lewis
  • KIPP
  • La Casita
  • LATU
  • Leo Casey
  • Leonie Haimson
  • Leticia James
  • Malcolm Smith
  • Matt Damon
  • mayoral control
  • mayoral election
  • Merryl Tisch
  • Mexico Teachers
  • Michael Benjamin
  • Michael Mulgrew
  • Michelle Rhee
  • Milton Friedman
  • MORE
  • MOSL
  • Movement of Rank and File Educators
  • Murry Bergtraum HS
  • National Education Association
  • nea
  • neo-liberalism
  • New Action
  • New Action-UFT
  • New Action/UFT
  • NEW Caucus
  • New Orleans
  • New York State Education Department
  • Newark
  • NPR
  • NY State Education Department
  • NY State Teacher Evaluations
  • NY Times
  • NY-GPS
  • NYC Teacher Evaluations
  • NYCDOE
  • nycore
  • NYSED
  • Obamacare
  • Office of Portfolio Planning
  • opt-out
  • Panel for educational policy
  • Paul Krugman
  • Paul Vallas
  • PAVE Academy
  • Pearson
  • PEP
  • pre-k
  • PS 15K
  • Public Advocate
  • race to the top
  • Rahm Emanuel
  • Rand Paul
  • Randi Weingarten
  • Reed Hastings
  • Reign of Error
  • Reza Aslan
  • Rockaway Theatre Company
  • scab
  • school closings
  • Seattle Teachers Association
  • Shael Polakow-Suransky
  • Skinny Awards
  • social justice unionism
  • SOS
  • Students United for Public Education
  • Substance
  • Success Academy
  • Success Charter Network
  • SUPE
  • Susan Fuhrman
  • Susan Ohanian
  • TDA
  • Teach for America
  • teacher data reports
  • teacher evaluation
  • teacher evaluations
  • Teachers College
  • TFA
  • The Daily Howler
  • The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Superman
  • The Wave
  • this week in ed notes
  • Tim Wise
  • Tony Avella
  • town hall
  • Tweed
  • Twinkie
  • UFT
  • UFT charter school
  • UFT elections
  • UFT history
  • union busting
  • Unity Caucus
  • WAGPOPS
  • Waiting for Superman
  • Washington DC
  • Win Back Wednesday
  • wnyc
  • Zealot
  • Zeke Vanderhoek

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ▼  October (71)
      • Change the Stakes General Meeting, Friday, October 25
      • Readings: Plutocrats, Toddler Testing, Looting Pen...
      • 12 Years a Slave - Under Bloomberg
      • The Madness Continues: Another Co-Loco Hearing Oct...
      • Change the Stakes: New York City Public School Pa...
      • Video, PS 196 Colocation Hearing: Brian De Vale Ca...
      • Parents Lead Massive Opt-Out of Kindergarten Tests...
      • PS 196k: Another SRO anti-colocation rally/hearing...
      • Parents Accuse DOE of Racist Co-locations
      • PEP Video: Community Says "No MORE Charters"
      • Monday: Public Hearing and Rally to Protest Co-Loc...
      • Parent, a NYC Principal, Calls for Removal of John...
      • Advice to MORE on Today's Delegate Assembly Discu...
      • Forecasting the July '14 AFT Convention: Chicago (...
      • Revisiting ObamaCare IT: Race to the Top - of Inco...
      • Video: Why Come to MORE Monthly Meeting This Satur...
      • Astounding: Government shutdown deal includes supp...
      • PS 29Q Principal Resigns After Protests
      • John King's Uncommon Schools Charters Opt Out of R...
      • Newark Teachers Union Rally: Enuf is Enuf
      • Video: PEP Oct 15 2013 - I Am Bergtraum
      • New Content at SusanOhanian.Org! Oct. 16, 2013
      • Government Open, Rockaway Theatre Co. is Back This...
      • Staten Island Democratic Club Calls for John King ...
      • Why Are Some New Jersey Teachers Voting Tea Party ...
      • PEP Notes - Tish James Rocks the House
      • UFT Charter Exempt From Teacher Evaluation System ...
      • Hitler Objects to Opt-Out Movement: High Stakes St...
      • TONIGHT AT PEP: Call on Mayoral Candidates to Reve...
      • Did Mulgrew Sign On to Recent NYC Race to the Top ...
      • Citizens of the World Charter To Use Dead Souls To...
      • Carol Smashes King
      • How Much Per Child Did Eva's Success Charters Spen...
      • Over Eva Invasion, Bergtraum ChLdr Warns of Securi...
      • Oct. 15: LET’S MARCH TOGETHER TO THE PEP TO FIGHT ...
      • NY State Ed Comm John King Enters Witness Protecti...
      • MORE Reflections on the Delegate Assembly
      • Reflections on the Common Core and High Stakes Tes...
      • ObamaCare IT: Race to the Top - of Incompetence
      • More MORE: Making an impact at the DA
      • Citizens of the World Charter Run By Eva's Husband...
      • Say NO to UFT Lame Attempt to Derail Opposition to...
      • What they spent but won't pay rent - Report from I...
      • A Memo on Eva Moskowitz's March and the #TaleofTwo...
      • NYC Public School Parents Comment on Charter Phon...
      • Media release Tues. Oct. 8, 2013: Parents and Advo...
      • NYC Public Schools Rally in Opposition to Charters...
      • Tuesday 9AM: Counter Charter School Rally at City ...
      • Ravitch in Park Slope Tues Night, Draws Crowds Nat...
      • Film - Teachers Unite: "Growing Fairness"
      • MORE Weekly Update #70: Are you coming out for Win...
      • Newark TU Rejects RTTT as Randi/Del Grosso Contrac...
      • The Daily News Deserves a Good Whopping for Witchh...
      • Video: MORE Brunch, Please
      • Today at noon: Protest at NBC Ed Deform Education ...
      • Rockaway’s Tale of Two Cities Under Bloomberg: Hea...
      • The Tale of Two Students, Or how can you possibly ...
      • Join Me and Other MOREistas This Saturday at MORE ...
      • Alex Caputo-Pearl Running for President of LA Teac...
      • Another Whine From Peter Goodman, Who Supported Un...
      • Fred Smith Discovers Test Question About Bloomberg...
      • Portelos Hearing Update: DOE Lawyers Pass DOE Empl...
      • Shael in the Eye of the Storm in Debate with Paren...
      • Co-Location Madness: PS 196, MS 582 Petition to St...
      • Rockaway Theatre Company Weekend Update: Last days...
      • Shame on "Journalists" Supporting E4E Closed Meeti...
      • Thursday Oct 3: Rally to Save I.S. 2 Staten Island
      • Video: Leonie Haimson and Jia Lee at CEC 15 High S...
      • Video- Inspiring Brooklyn New School Principal Ann...
      • Borowitz: Panicstricken Tea Party Supporters Flee ...
      • Vote James for Public Advocate Today
    • ►  September (80)
    • ►  August (70)
    • ►  July (66)
    • ►  June (62)
    • ►  May (60)
    • ►  April (67)
    • ►  March (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile