Playstation Tech Support

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 13 August 2013

Rubinstein: Success Academy Scores Based on High Attrition Plus Other Factors

Posted on 20:26 by Unknown
I wonder if this could start some kind of charter civil war. What ‘excuse’ is there for these other [charter] schools?  Surely behind closed doors they are accusing Success of some kind of manipulation, either by extensive test prep or by booting even more kids than they do. ... Gary Rubinstein
Gary Rubinstein follows up on his analysis of charter school chains like KIPP and Democracy Prep catastrophic test results with analysis of the one charter chain that blew everyone away. We posted commentary on Gary's previous post: Can We Close the Achievement Gap Between Success Academy and Democracy Prep, KIPP et al?

I loved that Success showed up the other charters as that brings the kind of scrutiny Gary provides as he does with all "miracle" schools. I left this comment on his blog:
We can certainly support the idea of 2 teachers in a room and that makes any comparison with public schools faulty. When you add the “disappeared” who most likely end up in public schools, the SA results don’t look so good given the different climate. So they have money to do this, often due to working young teachers to a bone and replacing them when worn out. Yes, cheap labor with 12 hour days and few career teachers. In no way scalable and over the long run as SA expands to 40 schools even sustainable. Watch the numbers as they get to higher grades. And the point that there is so much demand is bogus as we’ve been saying all along.
Yes, I absolutely support the idea of 2 teachers in a class in early grades -- actually, that is the private school model where they put novice teachers in with an experienced one. Great idea but not one that Eva really calls for in all public schools. Too bad because if she did she would not be as evil. But her aim is to undermine, not support public schools.

Gary makes these points:
I don’t think they really prove that there are super teachers out there who can get the ‘same kids’ to excel, even if it is just on standardized tests, since I’m not convinced they are truly the ‘same kids.’  But the ‘reformers’ should be very careful about this.  They already had Success as a big success story, as well as a bunch of others like KIPP and Democracy Prep.  Now they still have Success, but they have lost some of their schools they used to take credit for.  I’m not sure how they can reconcile their idea that test scores are an accurate measure of school quality with the fact that many of the schools they have been touting have lost their luster by that measure.
Here Gary looks at the key attrition rates.
So the next thing I looked at was their student attrition.  If they ‘lost’ many students, these scores are tainted.  Now there is only one Success school that has been around since 2007.  That school started with 83 kindergarteners and 73 first graders.  Those cohorts just tested in 6th and 7th grade, respectively.  The school has ‘lost’ a big chunk of those original 156 kids.  Of those 73 first graders in 2007, only 35 took the seventh grade test.  Of the 83 kindergarteners, only 47 took the sixth grade test last spring.  Overall, they have ‘lost’ 47% of the original two cohorts.  If this is one of the costs of having such high test scores, I’m not sure if it is worth it.
For the four cohorts that just took the fourth grade tests, those 316 students were, back in 2009, 443 kindergarteners, so they have ‘lost’ 29% of those cohorts.  Now their high test scores aren’t completely explained by this nearly 30% attrition rate, but it is still something worth noting as we consider if this program is ‘scalable’ or not.
 And talks about the teacher attrition rates:
When a school is ‘healthy,’ teacher are happy there and want to stay there.  The Success schools are known to have huge attrition of teachers, in the neighborhood of 50% per year. 
When push comes to shove, Success Academy will prove to be just another scam charter. Would NYC charter chief James Merriman send his kids there? Maybe he would given that Eva is abandoning the poor kids for the rich ones in Manhattan and gentrified areas of Brooklyn.

Read his entire piece.

And Perdido Street School too.
Just How Did They Get To Be So Successful At Succe...


Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Success Charter Network | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Video: Chicago Students Tossed From Board of Education Meeting
    Video of Chicago students taking over the Board of Education Meeting to save schools, prevent education cuts. From Xian Barrett: Published o...
  • Cavanagh Refused to Cooperate with NY Post Article on Mulgrew "Chicken" on Debate
    Every day I am reminded why Julie Cavanagh is not just MORE's presidential candidate but a true leader and why I defer to someone half m...
  • Change the Stakes to Discuss DOE's Bankrupt Student Promotion Policies, MORE Study Group on HST
    Our meetings are always open and all are welcome.  I can guarantee a lively discussion!  Promotion policies will be the focus on the agenda...
  • Parents Present Pearson With $38 Million Invoice for Use of Child Labor for Field Tests
    VISIT CHANGE THE STAKES Press Contacts: Kemala Karmen optout@parentvoicesny.org                                 Janine Sopp   janinesopp@gm...
  • I Echo Jersey Jazzman in Support for CORE in CTU Election on Friday
    Aside from everything else, just look at the ed deformers supporting Karen Lewis' opponents: The soon to be owned by Koch brothers Chica...
  • As Ed Deform Failures Mount, Mid-Course Correction for Former Cheerleaders Merrow, Goldstein, Weingarten
    Cheating is not the problem that must be addressed. It is the most visible and disturbing symptom of the disease, but the disease itself...
  • DOE Retaliates Against Children Who Opted-Out
    No matter how smart they are, the majority of kids who did not take standardized tests will be forced to attend summer school. ... Take...
  • MORE Weekly Update #65, Sept. 2, 2013
    Happy Labor Day from MORE! View this email in your ...
  • Dana Goldstein on L.A. Teacher Alex Caputo-Pearl and the Real Deal Behind Closing Schools
    On Monday, half the teachers at Crenshaw High School in Los Angeles found out they had been dismissed from their jobs as part of a "c...
  • "Waiting for Superman Makes List of Famous Documentaries That Were Shockingly Full of Crap
    Waiting for "Superman" -- Charter Schools Kind of Suck, Too [NOTE: SEE OUR RESPONSE TO WFS HERE] Read more: http://www.cracked....

Categories

  • 3020a hearing
  • Achievement First
  • achievement gap
  • AFT
  • AFT. UFT
  • Alex Caputo-Pearl
  • Andrew Cuomo
  • Anthony Weiner
  • APPR
  • arne duncan
  • atr
  • Barbara Byrd-Bennett
  • Barbara Morgan
  • Beth Hawkins
  • Bill de Blasio
  • Bill di Blasio
  • Bill Gates
  • Bill Keller
  • Bill Thompson
  • Brian Lehrer
  • Cami Anderson
  • Campbell Brown
  • Carol Burris
  • Chancellor Dennis Walcott
  • Change the stakes
  • Charles Blow
  • charter school
  • charter co-locations
  • charter school hearings
  • charter school lobby
  • charter schools
  • Chicago
  • Chicago Teachers Union
  • Chris Cerf
  • Christine Quinn
  • Christine Rubino
  • Citizens of the World charter
  • closing schools
  • Co-locations
  • Colocations
  • common core
  • Common Core Standards
  • Confessions of a Bad Teacher
  • Corey Booker
  • Danielson
  • Danielson framwork
  • David Steiner
  • Dearborn
  • Deborah Kenny
  • Democracy Prep
  • Dennis Van Roekel
  • Dennis Walcott
  • DFER
  • Diane Ravitch
  • District 14
  • drones
  • E3MN
  • E4E
  • ed deform
  • Education Nation
  • education reform
  • Educators 4 excellence
  • educators for excellence
  • eduwonkette
  • Eric Grannis
  • Erminia Claudio
  • Eva Moskowitz
  • Eva Moskowtiz
  • Evaluations
  • FairTest
  • field tests
  • Francesco Portelos
  • Fred Smith
  • Gates foundation
  • George Schmidt
  • Gotham schools
  • hannah Nguyen
  • Harlem Success Academy
  • Harlem Village Academy
  • high stakes testing
  • high stakes tests
  • High-Stakes Testing
  • House of Cards
  • ICE
  • inBloom
  • Jeb Bush
  • Jennifer Jennings
  • Jennifer Jones Rogers
  • Joe Lhota
  • Joel Klein
  • John B King
  • John King
  • John Liu
  • John Merrow
  • John Owens
  • jonathan halabi
  • Julie Cavanagh
  • Karen Lewis
  • KIPP
  • La Casita
  • LATU
  • Leo Casey
  • Leonie Haimson
  • Leticia James
  • Malcolm Smith
  • Matt Damon
  • mayoral control
  • mayoral election
  • Merryl Tisch
  • Mexico Teachers
  • Michael Benjamin
  • Michael Mulgrew
  • Michelle Rhee
  • Milton Friedman
  • MORE
  • MOSL
  • Movement of Rank and File Educators
  • Murry Bergtraum HS
  • National Education Association
  • nea
  • neo-liberalism
  • New Action
  • New Action-UFT
  • New Action/UFT
  • NEW Caucus
  • New Orleans
  • New York State Education Department
  • Newark
  • NPR
  • NY State Education Department
  • NY State Teacher Evaluations
  • NY Times
  • NY-GPS
  • NYC Teacher Evaluations
  • NYCDOE
  • nycore
  • NYSED
  • Obamacare
  • Office of Portfolio Planning
  • opt-out
  • Panel for educational policy
  • Paul Krugman
  • Paul Vallas
  • PAVE Academy
  • Pearson
  • PEP
  • pre-k
  • PS 15K
  • Public Advocate
  • race to the top
  • Rahm Emanuel
  • Rand Paul
  • Randi Weingarten
  • Reed Hastings
  • Reign of Error
  • Reza Aslan
  • Rockaway Theatre Company
  • scab
  • school closings
  • Seattle Teachers Association
  • Shael Polakow-Suransky
  • Skinny Awards
  • social justice unionism
  • SOS
  • Students United for Public Education
  • Substance
  • Success Academy
  • Success Charter Network
  • SUPE
  • Susan Fuhrman
  • Susan Ohanian
  • TDA
  • Teach for America
  • teacher data reports
  • teacher evaluation
  • teacher evaluations
  • Teachers College
  • TFA
  • The Daily Howler
  • The Inconvenient Truth Behind Waiting for Superman
  • The Wave
  • this week in ed notes
  • Tim Wise
  • Tony Avella
  • town hall
  • Tweed
  • Twinkie
  • UFT
  • UFT charter school
  • UFT elections
  • UFT history
  • union busting
  • Unity Caucus
  • WAGPOPS
  • Waiting for Superman
  • Washington DC
  • Win Back Wednesday
  • wnyc
  • Zealot
  • Zeke Vanderhoek

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ►  October (71)
    • ►  September (80)
    • ▼  August (70)
      • EdNotesOnline Blog 7th Anniversary: Reflections on...
      • Why Scott Stringer? Patrick Sullivan on the PEP an...
      • WHY De Blasio? Make Evil Eva Moskowitz Pay the Dam...
      • Urban Ed Blog Takes Shot at Peter Cunningham
      • Fred Smith in DN: One sad measure of Dr. King’s d...
      • Julie Cavanagh Analyzes Teacher Evaluation Options
      • Seattle public school teachers reject proposed con...
      • NY Times to Adopt TFA Model: Will Fire all Reporte...
      • John Owens' "Confessions of a Bad Teacher" Making ...
      • NY Times Distorts Mexico Teacher Revolt Which is A...
      • Ed Notes Redux: UFT Election Results, 1999 - New A...
      • Carol Burris: Common Core tests widen achievement ...
      • Classy: AFT leader Randi Weingarten cuts off 9-yea...
      • I Get Bar Mitzvahed (Again)
      • Howard Schwach: What in the world was the state th...
      • NYC Parent Urges: Consider opting out of the tests...
      • Rhee, Ravitch, Randi Too Upcoming in Philly
      • Ed Notes Redux: Why I Left New Action by James Eterno
      • Susan Ohanian: Liar! Liar! Pants on Fire! War on t...
      • Jim Horn New Book: The Mismeasure of Education
      • Common Bore Hysteria: Branding Common Core as Righ...
      • Political Tidbits: Norm in The Wave, August 23, 2013
      • Lamenting left attack on de Blasio from the differ...
      • EIA Reports: Weingarten Attacks “Austerity-Mongers...
      • NPE: News on Diane's Book, CPS Bulldozes La Casita...
      • Brian D'Agostino in DN: Mike’s school management m...
      • Christine Quinn's campaign events are "EMBARGOED U...
      • Jumping All Over Paul Krugman on Common Core
      • Here Comes Student Ratings of Teachers (Grades 3-1...
      • Why Leticia James for Public Advocate? Watch this ...
      • MORE Weekly Update: Come to our summer series on ...
      • Hilarious Parent Report on Tweed/DOE Test Disaster...
      • Howler Howls at Krugman and Press Corps
      • Chicago: Rahm sends police to protect crew sent to...
      • AFT Drops Hammer on Dearborn Federation of School ...
      • E4E Slammed in Minnesota by PEJAM
      • Matt Damon Still a Save Our Schools Superstar
      • Another Blogger Slams Eva's Success Academy Charte...
      • Neo-liberalism and Ed Deform and Krugman on Rand P...
      • Naison Calls for John King's Removal
      • Rubinstein: Success Academy Scores Based on High A...
      • "Waiting for Superman Makes List of Famous Documen...
      • A Weekend (not with Bernie) in Chicago
      • Can We Close the Achievement Gap Between Success A...
      • Rob Rendo on Common Core
      • The Howler on Times Test Editorial: The New York T...
      • Julie Cavanagh on Social Justice Unionism Prefaces...
      • Newsday: drop in scores cd strengthen opt out move...
      • Ravitch: Shock Doctrine Using Tests Will Spur Opt-...
      • The WAVE: Block Parties and Block Genealogy
      • Former NY St Ed Comm David Milton Steiner Opines i...
      • Network for Public Education News, August 8, 2013
      • NYSED APPROVES TROJAN HORSE PROJECT FOR PUBLIC SCH...
      • The New York Times fails the latest tests! - Daily...
      • Understanding Test Results as Shock Doctrine While...
      • Joel Klein: The Good News in Lower Test Scores. HU...
      • Parents and Educators Reject Official Explanations...
      • T-Day: For Deformers, Mission Accomplished
      • A Little Andy Borowitz Humor for a Warm Summer Day...
      • UFT History, Early Years from "City Unions", Chapt...
      • Newark Teachers Union Update: President Del Grosso...
      • PS 29 Parents Call Out Principal From Hell Jennife...
      • The Howler Howls at Maureen Dowd for Puff Piece on...
      • Bill de Blasio Makes His Move - Will UFT Members M...
      • MORE Update 63: How Do We Fight For a New Contract...
      • NY1 Coverage - Today: Last Chance to See Amazing R...
      • Video: State Senator Tony Avella Calls for Removal...
      • Network for Public Education Update: Tony Bennett ...
      • NYC Supervisor: Barbara Morgan is getting what she...
      • SFA, Scabs for America: How Much Heat Will Chicago...
    • ►  July (66)
    • ►  June (62)
    • ►  May (60)
    • ►  April (67)
    • ►  March (24)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile